Each article has been preserved in its original submitted form. No edits have been made to grammar, spelling or AGLC4 referencing.
By Kirsten Harkness
I INTRODUCTION
The twenty-first century young person straddles two distinct positions before the law. They are heralded as valuable advocates for reforming the future they will inherit, platformed where their advocacy serves to benefit a forward-thinking justice system. Yet, when in need of legal advocacy for everyday justiciable issues, they are left without sufficient institutional backing. This article contends that legal recognition of young people is selective rather than universal, with genuine legal participation only available to those who can afford to be heard. Youth access to justice requires comprehensive legal literacy and accessibility to community-based services, else legal recognition is destined to be a status conferred only on the privileged few the system deems useful.
II THE CHAMPIONED YOUTH
Even a cursory analysis of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child reveals that young people are to enjoy foundational rights in legal participation, in the right to express views freely in all matters affecting them,[1] and to freely seek, receive and impart information[2]. This participation has routinely been exercised in the prosecution of young people and matters pertaining to family law.[3] Yet following the 2015 Paris Agreement,[4] this past decade has been marked by the emergence of a novel avenue for youth legal participation: climate litigation.[5] This marked shift in youth self-advocacy is undoubtedly transformative in allowing young people to not only shape the trajectory of environmental law as the generation who will confront the brunt of climate change,[6] but to be celebrated as key legal actors with indispensable insight to future law reform.
The law recognises young people as possessing strengths instrumental to informing environmental law reform from locally in grassroots organising in the community to globally in litigating international law.[7] Youth across the world are a beacon of hope for the future of climate policy and rejuvenate the practical applications of children’s rights to legal participation, strengthening the mutualistic symbiotic relationship of the justice system and young climate advocates. Activist lawmakers turn to young people to guide climate-focussed reform, with youth-led cases more frequently resulting in the desired outcome than climate cases generally.[8]
A pertinent demonstration of the institutional power of youth climate litigation in an Australian context is exhibited in Waratah Coal Pty Ltd v Youth Verdict Ltd & Ors,[9] where a group of young plaintiffs, some as young as 13, successfully challenged a lease to develop a thermal coal mine. In finding that the development would perpetuate climate change and breach the rights of First Nations people[10] and children,[11] and infringing on the enjoyment of these rights without discrimination,[12] the court developed invaluable precedent on the life-threatening implications of climate change[13]. This landmark judgment further demonstrates that young people’s legal participation has indubitable value, as it compelled the court to rule on the impacts of climate change on First Australians and the imminent risks to safety, culture and health.
Much like the diverse array of litigants in Waratah Coal, many emerging climate cases platform Indigenous peoples are youth from marginalised communities,[14] further propounding the pivotal role of the courts in empowering youth legal participation. Sacchi et al. v Argentina et al is another pertinent case whereby a group of children from across Europe, the Americas, Asia and Africa argued that myriad respondent States have failed to prevent human rights violations caused by climate change and do not act to guarantee intergenerational equity.[15] Although this action did not succeed owing to the admissibility of the claim in its extraterritorial jurisdiction,[16] it acknowledges that young people worldwide share the young plaintiff’s plight and that climate change policy must be understood as significant and urgent on their behalf.[17]
These judgments and those of other emerging youth-led climate actions demonstrate that the justice system benefits greatly from the participation of young people, in exemplifying the necessity of future-focussed test cases rooted in the needs of the nascent generation.
However, youth legal participation in complex proceedings such as climate litigation requires significant institutional backing.[18] The success of large-scale youth advocacy can be credited to trust building between young litigants and lawyers,[19] access to information surrounding mechanisms in climate justice[20] and emotional guidance.[21] It must also be noted that action of this scope requires significant funding,[22] due to there often being complex legal and scientific considerations requiring costly evidence and lengthy proceedings. As no legal aid is available for civil environmental action, these costs are largely prohibitive and rely on the resourcing of litigation funders.[23]
The significant resourcing requirements of public interest litigation, especially that which is youth-led, breeds exclusivity and blocks many young people from this celebrated avenue of legal participation. As youth advocacy reaps value for the progression of law reform, there is a willingness to resource such action, yet this only permits the legal participation of a select few.
III THE INVISIBLE YOUTH
While progress in youth legal participation is burgeoning in large-scale advocacy, most young people sorely miss recognition by justice institutions upon confronting legal issues in their day-to-day lives. Significant institutional backing is made available to public interest litigation where youth are acclaimed supporters of policy and reform, yet when young people seek this support in return for justiciable issues of their own, they are met with a dire lack of information and resourcing. This sorely threatens the rights of young people to seek and receive legal information under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.[24]
Over four fifths of young people do not seek out legal services when managing a legal challenge and less than one fifth can discern when an issue is legal.[25] Instead, the majority handle it alone or seek informal advice from friends or family with others reporting doing nothing at all.[26] This reveals that young people are certainly facing challenges of a legal nature but are facing institutional barriers in understanding and access. When young people lack confidence in asserting their legal rights, unresolved justiciable issues compound manifesting in high levels of stress, unemployment, risks to personal safety, damage to family dynamics and displacement.[27]
This widening chasm in confidence in accessing legal support is entrenched institutionally. Victoria Legal Aid, as established and governed by Legal Aid Act 1978 (Vic), acts as an essential entry point for many to access free or low cost legal information and advice.[28] The legislation vests Victoria Legal Aid with the discretion to determine eligibility for legal assistance according to guidelines which are categorically narrow in scope.[29] Only 8% of households meet the income and asset tests for legal aid,[30] meaning that many young people slip through the cracks. The stringent eligibility criteria also present challenges for young people who would ordinarily be eligible, due to the administrative complexities in demonstrating income and assets. Unlike the funding and networks backing young people in climate advocacy, our legal system lacks the architecture built to reach young people navigating everyday legal disputes. Their recognition at law is not dependent on need but rather on satisfying arbitrary thresholds administered by statute rather than human discretion.
The barriers young people face in obtaining legal information and support In Victoria is augmented by a community legal sector in crisis. As a result of ongoing underfunding, on average, community legal centres across the country turn away 1000 people every day, over twice the number that they have the capacity to assist.[31] Victoria’s dedicated youth community legal service, Youthlaw, is not immune to these resourcing constraints. Although it recognises young people’s specific legal needs, this does not translate into the resourcing required to address them.[32] Hamstrung by the uncertainty of government grants and philanthropic funding, the plight of Youthlaw and other community legal centres demonstrate that the support available for high-level youth advocacy much outweighs that which sustains youth community legal services.
The gap in awareness and access of legal services is not felt evenly. The Victorian Government’s own justice strategy concedes that First Nations Victorians are often impeded in their access to culturally safe justice support services and fewer Aboriginal youth can engage in culturally safe legal support.[33] Culturally and linguistically diverse young people also require further institutional resourcing to meet their everyday legal needs including interpreters and translated legal materials. These emerging disparities amongst an already marginalised group at law demonstrate that recognition of need is not adequately coupled with the resourcing required to truly empower young people to navigate legal issues.
IV CONCLUSION
Where legal frameworks remain incomprehensible without the expertise of costly professionals, institutional support is vital to achieving genuine access to justice. The legal system does not lack the capacity to recognise young people, as it has demonstrated this in the resourcing youth-led climate advocacy. Where it fails is in extending this same recognition to young people’s grassroots legal needs. Young peoples’ access to justice cannot remain contingent on their instrumental role in law reform, it must be built as public infrastructure, capable of supporting every young person in navigating legal issues of their own.
[1] Convention on the Rights of the Child, opened for signature 20 November 1989, 1577 UNTS 3 (entered into force 2 September 1990) art 12.
[2] Ibid art 13.
[3] Tom Liefaard, ‘Child-friendly Justice: Protection and Participation of Children in the Justice System’ (2016) 88(4) Temple Law Review 905.
[4] See Paris Agreement, opened for signature 22 April 2016, [2016] ATS 24 (entered into force 4 November 2016).
[5] Aoife Daly and Leisl Muller, ‘Child/Youth Climate Litigation: Tracking Children’s Rights and Children’s Impact’ (2025) 82(3) Washington and Lee Law Review 1049, 1050-1 (‘Child/Youth Climate Litigation’).
[6] Ana Sanson and Marco Bellemo, ‘Children and youth in the climate crisis’ (2021) 45(4) BJPsych Bulletin 205.
[7] United Nations Development Programme, ‘Young people are key to solving the climate crisis – here’s why’, United National Development Program Climate Promise (Web Page, 3 August 2026) <https://climatepromise.undp.org/news-and-stories/young-people-are-key-solving-climate-crisis-heres-why>.
[8] Daly and Muller (n 5), 1065.
[9] Waratah Coal Pty Ltd v Youth Verdict Ltd & Ors (No 6) [2022] QLC 21 (‘Waratah Coal’).
[10] Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) s 28.
[11] Ibid s 26(2).
[12] Ibid s 15(2).
[13] Waratah Coal (n 9), [1486].
[14] Daly and Muller (n 5), 1050.
[15] Sacchi v Argentina (Committee on the Rights of the Child, Communication No 104/2019, 8 October 2021) [9].
[16] Ibid [24].
[17] Committee on the Rights of the Child, Open Letter to the Authors of Saachi et al v Argentina and Four Similar Cases (Letter, 11 October 2021) https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/Open_letter_on_climate_change.pdf.
[18] Aoife Daly, ‘Child and Youth Friendly Justice for the Climate Crisis: Relying on the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child’ (2024) 32 632.
[19] Ibid, 646.
[20] Ibid 649.
[21] Ibid, 650.
[22] Nicole Pain and Rachel Pepper, ‘Legal Costs Considerations in Public Interest Climate Change Litigation’ (2019) 211, 211.
[23] Ibid.
[24] Convention on the Rights of the Child (n 1) art 13.
[25] Georgina Rychner and Rochelle Jupp, Young people’s experience of legal problems (Suvrey Report, 2024) 2.
[26] Ibid.
[27] Ibid.
[28] Legal Aid Act 1978 (Vic).
[29] Ibid s 24.
[30] Nigel Balmer and Hugh McDonald, ‘Access to just this? Eligibility for legal aid in Australia and its implications’, Victoria Law Foundation (Web Page, June 2025) <https://www.victorialawfoundation.org.au/research-publications/access-to-just-this>.
[31] Community Legal Centres Australia, ‘More than legal services: Preventing crises, strengthening communities’ (Suvrey Report, November 2024).
[32] Ibid.
[33] First Peoples State Relations, ‘Victorian Government Aboriginal Affairs Report 2025’ (Web Page, updated 30 June 2026) <https://www.firstpeoplesrelations.vic.gov.au/victorian -government-aboriginal-affairs-report-2025/justice-safety/goal-16-aboriginal-victorians-have-access-safe-and-effective-justice-services>